Peer Review Guide
Remember that authors will appreciate both positive feedback and constructive criticism from you.
-
Writing Your Report
-
Complete the review questions form to indicate the relative strengths or weaknesses of the paper.
-
A referee may disagree with the author’s opinions, but they should be allowed to stand if they are consistent with the available evidence.
-
Remember that authors will welcome positive feedback as well as constructive criticism from you.
-
Answer Review Questions Form
-
The main factors you should provide advice on as a reviewer are the originality, presentation, relevance, and significance of the manuscript’s subject matter to the journal’s readership. The related link is here.
-
Make a Recommendation
|
.png)
.png)
